Master the classic sales interview question with proven strategies, example answers, and expert tips. Learn what interviewers really want to see.
1. Ask Questions
Understand needs first
2. Present Value
Match features to needs
3. Close Sale
Ask for commitment
This iconic interview question, popularized by The Wolf of Wall Street, is asked in sales, marketing, consulting, and business development interviews to assess multiple skills simultaneously:
Step 1: Ask Qualifying Questions (30 seconds)
"Before I tell you about this pen, I'd like to understand your needs better. What do you primarily use pens for? [Wait for answer] And what frustrates you most about the pens you currently use? [Listen] What features matter most to you - comfort, ink quality, professional appearance, or durability?"
Step 2: Identify Need & Position Solution (90 seconds)
[Assuming they said they sign important documents and current pens sometimes skip]
"I completely understand. When you're signing important contracts or client agreements, the last thing you need is a pen that skips or smudges. This pen is specifically designed for professionals like you who need reliability in critical moments.
Let me highlight three features that directly address what you mentioned:
First, it uses Swiss-made precision ink technology that never skips, even after sitting unused for months. That means when you reach for it for that important signature, it works every single time.
Second, the balanced weight and ergonomic grip mean you can sign dozens of documents without hand fatigue. I know you mentioned signing contracts frequently - this makes that process smooth and professional.
Third, the classic brushed metal design conveys professionalism. When you're presenting documents to clients, every detail matters. This pen makes a statement about your attention to quality."
Step 3: Create Value & Handle Objections (30 seconds)
"Now, at $25, this is more than a disposable pen. But consider this: you'll use this pen hundreds of times over the next few years. That's less than 10 cents per use. Plus, it's refillable, so you're making a smart investment. And here's something extra - we include a lifetime warranty and free refills for the first year."
Step 4: Close the Sale (15 seconds)
"Based on what you've shared about needing a reliable pen for important signings, this seems like a perfect fit. Would you prefer the classic silver or executive black finish? I can have it packaged and ready for you right away."
"Let me tell you a story. Last month, our CEO was in a critical board meeting. Just as the investors asked for his signature on the funding agreement, his cheap pen died. Awkward silence. Scrambling for a pen. Not the impression you want to make in a $10M deal.
This isn't just a pen - it's your silent professional partner. It's the writing instrument that never lets you down in those crucial moments. When you pull this out in a client meeting, it says 'I pay attention to details. I invest in quality.' That's the brand statement you're making before you even speak.
We position this as the pen for professionals who understand that success is in the details. Would you like to join the 50,000+ executives who trust this pen for their most important signatures?"
"Let me approach this systematically. First, situation analysis: May I ask what challenges you face with your current writing instruments? [Listen] Thank you. So I'm hearing three pain points: reliability, professional appearance, and value.
Now, let's look at the solution. This pen addresses each concern:
• Reliability: 99.9% ink flow consistency, tested over 50,000 uses
• Professional image: Designed in collaboration with luxury brands
• Value: $25 upfront, but $0.25 per refill vs $2 per disposable pen = ROI in 3 months
Based on this analysis, the business case is clear. The question isn't whether you can afford this pen - it's whether you can afford NOT to invest in reliable, professional writing instruments. Shall we proceed?"
"You know what's crazy? We live in 2025 - we have AI, we have smartphones, we have voice assistants. Yet somehow, we still need pens. Why? Because when you're signing a million-dollar contract, 'Hey Siri, sign this' just doesn't cut it. [Smile]
But here's the thing - if you're going to use a 'prehistoric' technology, at least use the best one. This pen is like the iPhone of pens. Sleek? Check. Never dies at the wrong moment? Check. Makes you look good in meetings? Double check.
Look, I could tell you about the German engineering or the precision-milled metal. But what matters is this: next time you're in that important meeting and someone asks 'can I borrow a pen?', you'll either hand them a cheap disposable or THIS. Which one makes you look like the person who has their life together?
So, ready to upgrade from the Stone Age to the Pen Age? [Smile]"
Objection: "I don't need a pen"
Response:
"I understand. Quick question - when was the last time you needed to sign something and couldn't find a pen? Probably more recent than you think. Even in our digital world, there are moments when only a pen works - signing contracts, taking quick notes in meetings, marking up documents. This is about being prepared for those crucial moments. Plus, would you consider it as a gift for a colleague or client who would appreciate it?"
Objection: "It's too expensive"
Response:
"I appreciate you being budget-conscious - that shows good financial sense. Let's look at this another way: if you buy a $2 disposable pen every month because they run out or break, that's $24 per year. This pen costs $25 once and lasts for years with $2 refills. After just the first year, you're saving money. Plus, think about the cost of NOT having a reliable pen when you need it most - like that contract signing I mentioned. What's that awkward moment worth to you?"
Objection: "I'll think about it"
Response:
"Absolutely, I respect that. Before you go, may I ask what's giving you pause? Is it the price, or are you not sure about the features? [Address specific concern] Also, I should mention we're running a promotion this week - 20% off plus a free premium refill. This offer ends Friday, so if you're interested, now would be the ideal time. But I don't want to pressure you - how about I give you my card and you can reach out if you'd like to move forward?"
Interviewers ask this classic question to assess: 1) Sales skills - can you identify needs and present solutions, 2) Communication - can you articulate value clearly and persuasively, 3) Confidence - how you handle pressure and improvisation, 4) Problem-solving - your approach to understanding customer needs, 5) Listening skills - whether you ask questions before pitching, 6) Creativity - how you differentiate a common product. It's popular in sales, marketing, consulting, and business development roles. The question tests your ability to sell anything by focusing on customer needs rather than product features.
The best approach: 1) Ask questions first - "What do you use pens for? What frustrates you about your current pen?" 2) Listen to identify needs, 3) Present 2-3 features that address their specific needs (not all features), 4) Use benefit-focused language - "This comfortable grip means you can write for hours without fatigue", 5) Create value - explain why it's worth the price, 6) Handle objections proactively, 7) Close confidently - "Shall I package one for you?" The worst approach is immediately listing features without understanding needs. Great salespeople ask questions, listen, and then present relevant solutions.
Stand out by: 1) Being conversational and natural (not robotic), 2) Asking unexpected qualifying questions that show strategic thinking, 3) Using storytelling - "Let me tell you about my client who...", 4) Demonstrating the pen while talking (if physically present), 5) Creating emotional connection - "Imagine signing your dream home contract with this elegant pen", 6) Showing competitive knowledge - "Unlike cheap pens that leak, this...", 7) Following up with after-sale care - "I'll include a free refill and my card for any questions", 8) Being confident but not pushy. Most candidates list features; standout candidates create an experience.
Ask: 1) "What do you primarily use pens for?" (identifies use case: signing documents, note-taking, sketching), 2) "What frustrates you about your current pen?" (reveals pain points), 3) "What features matter most to you?" (priorities: comfort, ink quality, appearance, durability), 4) "Do you prefer ballpoint, gel, or fountain pens?" (preferences), 5) "What's your budget range?" (qualification), 6) "Where do you typically use pens?" (context: office, field, meetings), 7) "How often do you lose pens?" (identifies need for affordable vs premium). These questions demonstrate consultative selling and help you tailor your pitch to their actual needs rather than generic features.
Yes, absolutely attempt to close! This demonstrates: 1) Confidence and completion of sales process, 2) Understanding that sales isn't just talking - it requires asking for commitment, 3) Comfort with potential rejection (they might say no), 4) Real-world sales behavior. Use assumptive closes like "Shall I package one for you?" or "Would you prefer black or blue ink?" or alternative closes "Would you like one or two pens?" Even if they say no, you've shown you understand the full sales cycle. Most candidates forget this crucial step and just stop after listing features, missing the opportunity to demonstrate closing skills.
This is testing objection handling. Respond: 1) Acknowledge - "I understand you don't need one right now", 2) Probe deeper - "Just curious, when was the last time you needed to write something down and couldn't find a pen?", 3) Reframe the need - "Even in our digital world, there are moments when only a pen works - signing contracts, jotting quick notes in meetings, having clients sign documents", 4) Create new need - "What about as a backup? Or for client meetings where you need to look professional?", 5) Offer alternative - "Perhaps as a gift for a colleague or client who would appreciate it?". The key is staying positive, not being pushy, and creatively finding angles without being aggressive.
Aim for 2-3 minutes maximum. Structure: 30 seconds asking questions and listening, 60-90 seconds presenting relevant features and benefits based on their answers, 30 seconds handling potential objections and creating urgency, 15 seconds attempting to close. The key is being conversational and interactive - this should feel like a dialogue, not a monologue. If you talk for 5+ minutes without pausing, you've lost them. If you finish in 30 seconds, you haven't demonstrated enough sales skills. Practice timing yourself. The best answers are concise, interactive, and focused on the customer's needs rather than endless feature lists.
Avoid: 1) Immediately listing features without asking questions, 2) Talking too much without listening, 3) Focusing on features instead of benefits ("it has a metal clip" vs "the clip keeps it secure so you never lose it"), 4) Being too aggressive or pushy, 5) Not attempting to close the sale, 6) Apologizing or being too timid, 7) Saying "it's just a pen" (undermines your pitch), 8) Listing every single feature (overwhelming), 9) Not handling objections, 10) Speaking in monotone without energy. Remember: great salespeople ask questions, listen actively, present relevant solutions, and confidently ask for the sale while being respectful.
Yes, appropriate humor can work well: 1) It shows confidence and personality, 2) Makes your pitch memorable, 3) Builds rapport. Examples: "You know what they say - the pen is mightier than the sword, and much easier to carry through airport security" or "In a world of dying phone batteries, this pen has 100% uptime guaranteed". However: keep it light and professional, don't make it the focus (humor should enhance, not replace, your sales technique), read the room (if interviewer seems serious, stay professional), ensure humor is appropriate and inoffensive. Humor works best when it's natural to your personality, not forced. If you're not naturally funny, stick to confident, professional delivery.
Sales roles: Focus on closing techniques, objection handling, creating urgency, asking for the sale multiple times if needed. Marketing roles: Emphasize brand positioning, target audience, unique value proposition, emotional benefits, storytelling. Consulting roles: Show structured thinking (situation-problem-solution), ask strategic questions, demonstrate ROI, data-driven benefits. Business development: Focus on relationship building, long-term value, partnership language, follow-up approach. Customer success: Emphasize post-sale support, customer journey, retention benefits, building trust. Technical roles: Highlight product specifications, engineering quality, technical superiority with evidence. Tailor your approach to showcase skills most relevant to the specific role you're interviewing for.
Use our AI-powered mock interview tool to practice this and 100+ other common questions